When Cabinet Painting Is Enough And When New Doors Make Sense
Start with the boxes. When the carcasses are square, dry and solidly screwed to the wall, cabinet painting on the doors you already own is nearly always the smarter money.
Then look at the doors. Lifting thermofoil, veneer worn through, water-swollen particleboard and panels cracked end to end are beyond a coating. A few of those means spot replacement. A whole kitchen of them means refacing.
Style is the third reason. Many people want the cathedral arch gone. New shaker uppers with painted lowers is often the best fit, and the cathedral door cabinet painting page compares that option with filling the arch.
What Refacing Costs Compared With Cabinet Painting
Here, full-kitchen cabinet painting mostly costs from $2,500 up to $5,500. Refacing generally falls in a $3,000 to $10,000 band, with door material and piece count setting where in that band a kitchen lands.
Tearing out and replacing everything usually costs about $15,000 at the low end and can top $40,000. One replacement door costs a few hundred dollars, and after spraying it looks like every other door in the run. Swapping only the arched uppers lands somewhere between cabinet painting and full refacing, because the lowers keep their own doors. Plan around the number printed on your written quote.
New Doors Match Only When Everything Is Sprayed Together
A freshly primed new door next to a thirty-year-old original will stand out unless both get finished together. So the entire run goes through cabinet painting in one session, and every door carries identical primer, identical topcoat, identical coat count and identical sheen.
The door style has to fit in just as much as the colour does. A shaker door in a kitchen full of raised panels looks like a repair, so replacements either match the existing profile or change a whole group, such as all the uppers.
Hinge boring is the detail that changes a quote. Most 1990s East Credit kitchens use concealed European hinges, so new doors are bored to match. Soft-close upgrades done during the same visit are listed under cabinet hardware and soft-close hinges.
Painting New Shaker Doors With The Frames Gives One Clean Colour
When a large share of the doors are replaced, we order unfinished or primed shaker doors and run them through cabinet painting with the face frames. The frames and the new doors then share one sprayed colour and one sheen.
Doors bought pre-finished from a supplier rarely match a sprayed face frame exactly. Cabinet painting the whole run together avoids that mismatch and keeps the kitchen looking like one piece of work.
Solid 1990s Boxes Are Worth Keeping
The boxes in most East Credit kitchens are built well enough to last another thirty years. Tearing them out to install new boxes of similar or lower quality is a poor trade.
Keeping the boxes also keeps the counters, the sink, the plumbing and the backsplash where they are. That is the main reason refacing and cabinet painting cost so much less than a new kitchen.